Is 3I/ATLAS the Oldest Comet We've Ever Seen?

Top view of the Milky Way galaxy showing the estimated orbits of both our sun and the 3I/ATLAS comet. 3I/ATLAS is shown in red dashed lines, and the sun is shown in yellow dotted lines. The large extent of 3I’s orbit into the outer thick disk is clear, while the sun stays nearer the core of the galaxy.

What if a visitor arrived at our cosmic doorstep, not just from another star system, but from another era entirely? Here at FreeAstroScience.com, we seek to explain complex scientific principles in simple terms, and today we have a truly remarkable story to share. A brand-new object, named 3I/ATLAS, has just been discovered streaking through our Solar System, and it’s unlike anything we’ve seen before. It’s a messenger from the deep past, carrying secrets about the galaxy's history. We invite you, our valued reader, to join us as we unpack the incredible story of this ancient wanderer.

Top view of the Milky Way galaxy showing the estimated orbits of both our sun and the 3I/ATLAS comet. 3I/ATLAS is shown in red dashed lines, and the sun is shown in yellow dotted lines. The large extent of 3I’s orbit into the outer thick disk is clear, while the sun stays nearer the core of the galaxy. Credit: M. Hopkins/ÅŒtautahi-Oxford team. Base map: ESA/Gaia/DPAC, Stefan Payne-Wardenaar, CC-BY-SA 4.0



Who Is This Mysterious Interstellar Visitor?

On July 1, 2025, astronomers using the ATLAS survey telescope in Chile spotted a faint object moving through our cosmic neighborhood. After calculating its trajectory, they confirmed it wasn't from around here. Its incredible speed and wide, open orbit proved it was an interstellar object (ISO)—a small body, like a comet or asteroid, that originated from another star system and has been drifting through the void for eons .

This makes 3I/ATLAS only the third such visitor ever confirmed. You might remember the first two:

  • 1I/‘Oumuamua (2017): A strange, elongated, and seemingly inert object that tumbled through our system, leaving more questions than answers .
  • 2I/Borisov (2019): A more conventional, though still fascinating, comet rich in carbon monoxide .

3I/ATLAS, however, seems to be in a class of its own. It's already showing signs of being an active comet, and it's here to challenge our understanding of how planetary systems form across the Milky Way .

Why Is 3I/ATLAS So Radically Different?

The excitement surrounding 3I/ATLAS comes from its unique properties, which we can analyze using powerful new tools like the ÅŒtautahi–Oxford model. This model combines data from the Gaia space telescope with galactic dynamics to predict the properties of the ISO population . When we applied this model to 3I/ATLAS, the results were stunning.

An Origin From the Galactic Suburbs

Our Sun, like most of the stars we see, resides in the "thin disk" of the Milky Way—a relatively flat, dense plane of stars . But our galaxy also has a "thick disk," a more diffuse halo of older stars that orbit above and below this main plane .

The trajectory of 3I/ATLAS is exceptionally steep. Its high vertical velocity places its origin squarely in this ancient thick disk, making it the very first object we've ever observed from this galactic component . Think of it this way: if our Solar System is in a bustling city, 3I/ATLAS is a visitor from a remote, ancient mountain village we've only ever seen from a distance.

A Potentially Ancient Relic

Because the thick disk is populated by older stars, any object originating there is likely to be ancient itself . Using a statistical method called the age-velocity dispersion relation, we've estimated the age of 3I/ATLAS. The results are mind-boggling: there's a strong possibility it is between 7.6 and 14 billion years old .

To put that in perspective, our own Solar System is about 4.5 billion years old . This means 3I/ATLAS may have formed billions of years before the Earth even existed, making it "very likely to be the oldest comet we have ever seen," according to astronomer Matthew Hopkins . While there are large uncertainties in this age estimate, and we can't trace it to a specific parent star, the evidence strongly points to it being an incredibly old relic .

A Water-Rich Composition?

The ÅŒtautahi–Oxford model also makes a testable prediction about what 3I/ATLAS is made of. Based on its thick disk origin, the model suggests it should be significantly more water-rich than the previous two ISOs .

Right now, it's too far away for us to easily detect that water. But as it gets closer to the Sun, the heat will cause its ices to sublimate, creating a visible coma and tail . By studying the gases in that coma, some of the world's largest telescopes will be able to test this prediction directly .

Does This Mean We'll Find More Like It?

The discovery of 3I/ATLAS isn't just a one-off event; it has profound implications for the future of astronomy.

For one, 3I/ATLAS appears to be quite large—perhaps up to 10 km in diameter, which is much bigger than ‘Oumuamua or Borisov . This suggests that the population of ISOs might contain more large objects than we previously thought .

More importantly, its discovery gives us an incredible confidence boost for what's to come. The Vera C. Rubin Observatory is set to begin its survey of the sky soon, and models predicted it would find between 5 and 50 new ISOs . The discovery of a large, unusual object like 3I/ATLAS suggests that we may hit the higher end of that estimate, revealing a galaxy teeming with these fascinating messengers .

A Message From Across Time and Space

The story of 3I/ATLAS is a powerful reminder of how dynamic and interconnected the galaxy truly is. It's not a collection of isolated islands but a vast, churning system where material is exchanged between stars over billions of years. We've determined that it's highly unlikely 3I/ATLAS shares a common origin with either ‘Oumuamua or Borisov; it is a truly independent traveler.

This object is a physical piece of another, older planetary system delivered right to our doorstep. By studying it, we're not just looking at a comet—we're looking back in time, gaining direct evidence of how planetesimals form and evolve in different galactic environments.

Here at FreeAstroScience.com, we believe you should never turn off your mind and must keep it active at all times, because, as the saying goes, the sleep of reason breeds monsters. Objects like 3I/ATLAS are nature's way of waking us up, challenging our assumptions, and pushing us toward a deeper understanding of our place in the cosmos. We hope you'll come back to learn with us as we continue to follow this incredible story.


Matthew J. Hopkins et al, From a Different Star: 3I/ATLAS in the context of the ÅŒtautahi-Oxford interstellar object population model, arXiv (2025). DOI: 10.48550/arxiv.2507.05318 ,

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post