I’ve been watching the Global Sumud Flotilla with a mix of unease and déjà vu. The ships, the banners, the slogans—on the surface, it all feels noble. Who doesn’t want to see aid reaching Gaza, where people are starving under bombardment? But scratch beneath the paint, and something darker comes through: this flotilla looks less like real help, more like theatre. And I don’t want a war in Italy sparked by what is essentially a social media showcase.
The Italian government offered a practical compromise: unload aid in Cyprus, then move it safely to Gaza through the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem. It wasn’t perfect, but it was concrete, legal, and above all—possible. The flotilla rejected it outright. Why? Because compromise doesn’t trend. What trends is defiance, livestreams of boats in peril, and hashtags about "breaking the siege".
But Gaza’s children can’t eat hashtags. They can’t cure wounds with viral videos.
The Seduction of Spectacle
This flotilla is sailing in dangerous waters—literally. Intelligence services are warning of possible Israeli attacks in the coming hours. Italy has already dispatched navy vessels, but not as escorts—only for humanitarian rescue, should the inevitable crisis erupt. Spain too is moving ships. And here’s the point: every European move to "protect" these boats risks dragging us into confrontation with Israel. Do we really want Italy’s navy to stumble into war because activists refused a safe corridor?
I hear the activists saying: "We must break the illegal blockade." I don’t deny the brutality of that blockade. But humanitarian corridors exist, even if insufficient. The UN says Gaza needs 600 trucks of aid a day. Right now, Israel lets in barely 60. The flotilla won’t change that arithmetic. At best, fifty small boats will bring symbolic tons of rice. At worst, they will trigger another bloodbath.
And symbolism, however moving, doesn’t fill an empty stomach.
When Help Becomes Self-Indulgence
I keep thinking of the sound of a port—metallic clanks, crates hitting pavement, forklifts beeping. That’s the sound of real aid arriving. Contrast that with the staged livestreams of activists announcing, "We will not stop, even under threat!" It feels less about food for Gaza, more about glory for themselves.
This isn’t solidarity; it’s self-indulgence. Genuine solidarity would mean pushing governments to triple, quadruple, multiply by ten the aid trucks allowed into Gaza daily. It would mean cutting deals that are dull but effective, opening crossings that are politically messy but lifesaving. Instead, the flotilla chooses theatre over logistics, and risks lives—both Gazan and Italian—for a headline.
Gaza Needs Bread, Not Martyrs
I want to say this bluntly: Gaza doesn’t need martyrs. It needs bread. It needs antibiotics. It needs the quiet miracle of trucks crossing borders without cameras.
The Global Sumud Flotilla says they are "breaking the siege". But from here in Italy, I see them breaking something else: trust. Trust in diplomacy, trust in humanitarian neutrality, trust that Italy can remain a nation that helps without stumbling into war.
As President of Free Astroscience, I’ve spent years translating complex science into everyday language. Let me translate this situation for you, simply: if aid doesn’t reach the people who need it, it isn’t aid—it’s performance.
The Hard Truth
Do I believe the activists care about Gaza? Yes. Do I believe they’re effective? No.
What Gaza needs is boring, bureaucratic, grinding diplomacy. What it doesn’t need is another flotilla turned battlefield, with Italy dragged unwillingly into the smoke. Because if one of those ships is sunk, if Italian lives are lost, then our streets will fill with the sound of sirens—not solidarity.
And let me ask you this: do we want our cities—Naples, Rome, Palermo—to pay for a spectacle staged for screens?
I don’t.
Final Thought
The sea is beautiful, but it’s also cruel. Waves don’t care about justice, and missiles even less. Let’s stop romanticising floating caravans of protest and start demanding what truly matters: real, massive, unglamorous aid for Gaza.
Anything else is theatre. And Gaza has no time left for theatre.
Post a Comment